Best Meal Replacement Shakes For Men And Women

Best Meal Replacement Shakes For Men And Women – Top Picks 2017

More and more health-conscious people implement the best meal replacement shakes in their diets. As a result, one may ask: what is the main ground for this growing phenomenon?

For starters, the best meal replacement shakes are recommended by nutritionists and doctors. Primarily, they are loaded with a broad range of vitamins and minerals. Plus, they are efficient and doubly convenient. Not to mention that they are genuinely healthy.

If you follow a high protein/low carb diet, preparing various healthy meals per day is quite challenging. So, when your schedule doesn’t allow you to do so, and you want to find a viable solution, a protein meal replacement might be your best choice.

This is a great option in comparison to skipping a meal altogether or choosing an attractive but less healthy option. On the same note, meal replacement shakes are much better than protein bars that present high levels of sugar. Nonetheless, as with anything in life, you should ensure that solid food accounts for the largest percentage of your meals.

In this article, we want to address some of the most popular questions regarding meal replacement shakes. We’ll also present their advantages, and other valuable information.

Protein Shakes Vs. Meal Replacement Shakes

First things first! Protein shakes and meal replacement shakes are often mixed up. Both are recommended for attaining athletic performance goals. Still, there is a crucial distinction between them. The fundamental difference lies in the calorie count and the benefits offered.


Meal replacement shakes or other similar products such as soups, bars, and snacks aim at substituting one or two meals. They are meant to be more filling and satisfying while presenting fewer calories than actual meals.

As a general rule, they are formulated for weight maintenance. Moreover, they offer a mixture of critical nutrients and vitamins that your body depends on. Plus, they are loaded with protein while being low in carbs. Typically, meal replacement shakes have between 200 to 400 calories.

On the other hand, a protein shake isn’t meant to substitute a meal as a serving features less than 200 calories.

Protein Content

Typically, protein shakes offer approximately 25 g of protein per serving. On the other hand, meal replacement shakes that are implemented into a healthy diet are lower in protein, containing about 10 grams of it. Protein plays a vital role in muscle-building, while also contributing to weight loss.

Fat Content

Moving on to fat content, the majority of protein shakes are low in fat. On the other hand, the fat content in the best meal replacement shakes depends on the ingredients used.

Furthermore, meal replacement shakes that are low in carbs are higher in fat and are recommended especially for low-carb diets.

According to research published in the Journal of International Society of Sports Nutrition, choosing meal replacement shakes that are loaded with omega-3 fatty acids is helpful for gaining muscle and losing weight.​

Carbohydrate Content

Protein shakes aren’t meant to replace meals. That is why they contain less than 5 grams of carbohydrates. In comparison, meal replacement shakes include carbohydrates, making the shake more nutritious. This is why they are called meal replacement shakes.

They are recommended for dieting because they present a high level of dietary fiber. This is a compound that keeps you full while also enhancing your digestion. Fiber plays a leading role in aiding you to consume fewer calories throughout the day.

Vitamins and Minerals

As a general rule, protein shakes don’t offer other vitamins and minerals than the ones provided by the protein source. For instance, in the case of shakes featuring dairy products, they would provide calcium.

On the other hand, the best meal replacement shakes contain other minerals and vitamins as well. So, they provide you with more health benefits.​

Meal Replacement Shakes and Weight Loss


Many people include the best weight loss shakes in their eating routine for one reason: to lose weight. They are easy to prepare, they’re low in calories, yet nutritious, and promise positive results. In addition, they make it easier for you to manage your caloric intake.

If you’re on the lookout for the best meal replacement shakes for weight loss, there are plenty of things you should factor in. Since so many people are looking for effective ways of losing weight and staying fit, many choose meal replacement shakes.

It’s true that they can be genuinely helpful, for numerous reasons. Nonetheless, it is essential to implement these in your diet in an efficient and smart way.

A key factor to successfully losing weight is to keep track of your calorie intake. These meal replacement shakes can aid you in this respect. You ought to substitute two meals; lunch and breakfast, for instance. However, you should pay attention to number of calories you must consume to reach your goals.

According to studies, the best weight loss shakes have been proven to attain their goals. They are just as effective as counting calories. What is more, other studies have counteracted the myth claiming that shakes work for a limited timeframe.

On the opposite, such weight loss shakes aid people to keep their new weight for more time. That is due to their convenience: they make the whole process of counting calories more accessible. On that note, meal replacement shakes are quite practical in losing weight healthily.

On the same note, if you embrace an appropriate exercising routine targeted for your goals and body type, you’ll boost your chances of reaching your weight loss goals.

Exercise contributes to burning calories while aiding your body to get rid of the stored fat. Not to mention that it enhances your cardiovascular health, reduces stress, and improves your mood and energy. So, by simply combining a healthy diet, meal replacement shakes and workouts, you’ll be on the right path.​

Buying the Best Weight Loss Meal Replacement Shakes


If you want to buy the best weight loss shakes or shake powder, there are a few things you should consider. Although it’s recommended to prepare your own weight loss shakes, that’s not always a possibility. In these situations, you should take into consideration the following.

  • Meal replacement shakes should provide a balance between calories, carbohydrates, dietary fiber and protein, and essential minerals and vitamins.
  • Ideally, you should compare distinct brands and read many meal replacement shake reviews before making a choice.
  • Too few calories or too much sugar can make you eat more, which defeats your objective of losing weight.
  • If you are following a low carb diet, look for low-carb meal replacement shakes reviews.
  • Make sure you read the label before purchasing a shake. Some include more sugar than protein, and others have artificial flavors and preservatives.
  • Before adding supplements to your diet, make sure you consult with your doctor.
  • When it comes to countertop meal replacement shakes, you should know they are a form of processed food. So, you should consume them in moderation.​

Best Meal Replacement Shakes for Women


Consuming healthy meal replacement shakes instead of one or two meals is a popular strategy among women who wish to lose weight. A study in the International Journal of Obesity and Related Metabolic Disorders backs up this information. Nonetheless, as it is expected, not every shake will serve the same purpose.

The most effective meal replacement shakes for weight loss have the right combination of ingredients, which keep you satiated and fulfilled until the next meal. One thing you should bear in mind is that commercial meal replacement shakes feature a wide range of additives and sugar. On that note, these may not provide the same results as homemade weight loss shakes.

Calorie count

Based on the American College of Sports Medicine, a woman should consume approximately 1,200 calories per day. In other words, if your meals consisting of whole foods contain about 900 calories, your shake should have 300 calories, at the very least.

Failing to offer your body what it requires will deprive it of essential vitamins and nutrients. That can be a counteractive strategy, in the long term. On the other side, if you implement too many meal replacement shakes in your diet, you might end up gaining weight.

We recommend you to consult with your dietitian regarding the number of calories you should eat per day to accomplish your weight loss goals. The types of meal replacement shakes for women depend on each person’s objectives and specifications.

Fill up with protein

Everyone knows that protein is the most satisfying macronutrient. It keeps you full for a long time, aiding you to cut down on unhealthy snacks and drinks. Moreover, protein also grows thermogenesis (heat production) in the body, making you lose more calories.

In the same regard, if you’re following a strength-training program and you’re embracing a healthy meal replacement diet, eating enough protein will support healthy fat loss and muscle gain.

What are the sources of protein you could add to your meal replacement shakes? Brown rice, tofu, pea, whey or casein powder, Greek yogurt, seed, and nuts are just a few excellent suggestions.

Fiber is just as important

Veggies and fruit are packed with vitamins, antioxidants, and minerals while also being loaded with fiber. Most meal replacement shakes contain a blend of these components.

Considering that fiber is a structural component that isn’t digestible, that makes it virtually free of calories. At the same time, it creates a feeling of satiety, keeping you full for a long time.

In this view, adding fiber to your meal replacement shakes will make them more fulfilling. This way, they will help you to keep your weight loss goals on the right track. We would suggest you add blackberries, strawberries, blueberries, apple slices, spinach, and so on. Not only that they make your weight loss shakes taste great, but they are really healthy for you.

What other ingredients should you add to your weight loss shakes?

Protein for women

As a general rule, your meal replacement shakes should provide you with all the nutrients you would normally get from a full meal. We’re talking about protein, fiber, healthy fats, and carbohydrates. Ideally, you should add a low-calorie base for your weight loss shakes, such as soy milk, coconut or almond milk or low-fat cow’s milk.

The next step is to incorporate your choice of fruit, veggies, and protein. Other ingredients that represent sources of healthy fats include avocado, walnuts, almond butter, flax seeds or chia seeds.

Bear in mind, though, that sugar shouldn’t be on your ingredient list. That will boost the calorie intake. Plus, fruits are natural sweeteners, making your meal replacement shakes taste delicious.​

Best Meal Replacement Shakes for Men

Protein powder

A study you can find in the International Journal of Obesity and Related Metabolic Disorders says that the best meal replacement shakes counteract obesity and promote healthy weight loss. According to official data, a man needs about 2500 calories to maintain his weight.

It also appears that skipping breakfast is a popular trend among many men. Nonetheless, this is a harmful habit, which can have long-term repercussions on your health. What is more, a study in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition published in 2012 highlighted that the men who skipped breakfast were at a higher risk of suffering from type 2-diabetes.

This is where meal replacement shakes kick in. They are effortless to prepare, don’t require any cooking skills and they can substitute a breakfast consisting of solid foods. Since meal replacement shakes offer a feeling of satiety, you won’t have the urge to get unhealthy snacks.

Meal Replacement Shakes for Healthy Weight Gain

Milk shake for men

Although this may appear like a paradox, many people are underweight. Underlying health conditions and inadequate nutrition are the main grounds to this problem.

Based on studies, the number of underweight men decreased over time. Still, there are many people who deal with this problem.

In this respect, implementing the best meal replacement shakes that are high in calories will enable you to gain weight and live a healthy lifestyle. The majority of weight-gain products you may find on the market may come with side effects. So, you can consider preparing your own meal replacement shakes to be sure that you only add beneficial ingredients.

Controlling ingredients and the quantities is highly recommended to avoid messing up your metabolism. Supplements and sugar are common compounds found in weight-gain meal replacement shakes.

So, consider the following alternative: combine whole milk, peanut butter, whey protein, flax seeds or a banana, and there you have it. You’ll manage to create a healthy, nutritious meal replacement shake.

By adding protein and carbohydrates, you stimulate muscle gain. At the same time, the flax seeds present the perfect balance of healthy omega-three fatty acids and fiber. These are only some suggestions to make excellent meal replacement shakes.​

Post-Workout Meal Replacement Shakes

An exercise routine requires a healthy dieting plan as well. In this respect, we find the post-workout meal replacement shakes to be crucial, especially if your aim is to lose weight.

After working out, your body concentrates on building and repairing muscle tissue. That necessitates energy. Considering that top meal replacement shakes include carbs, protein, and fluid, that aids you to keep your calories in check.

The Importance of Post-Workout Meal Replacement Shakes

Workout diet

You already know that a great workout makes you burn calories and sweat while targeting your muscles. In about 30 minutes after you have completed a workout, your body needs to rehydrate. This way, it can restore the energy, while growing and repairing the muscles.

Plus, that enhances the recovery process. According to this source, protein contributes to repairing and building muscles, while carbs help ensure the recovery process.

Experts also highlight that the timing is just as crucial. On that note, you should eat within 45 minutes after working out.Bear in mind that even if you follow a weight loss routine, building muscle is crucial. In this respect, adding protein to your post-workout meal replacement shakes is highly recommended.

Most of the times, after working out, you feel too exhausted to cook something or have something to eat. That is why preparing shakes for weight loss is a convenient option to refuel after exercising.​

Calories Still Count, Though

Even though your post-workout meal is crucial, calories are still important, especially if you wish to lose weight. That’s why we advise you to avoid surpassing 300 calories when you prepare your meal replacement shakes.

You should combine protein and carbs to get the most out of each. Also, it might be a good idea to diminish the amount of fat you eat after working out. But you shouldn’t exclude it at all.

Making Your Own Meal Replacement Shakes

Choclate Milk Shake

If you wish to prepare your own post-workout shake, you might be looking for meal replacement shake recipes. Choosing this alternative over a commercial protein shake meal replacement is highly recommended. This way, you don’t ingest a range of additives and unwanted sugar.

On the contrary, you get a combination of fiber, minerals, nutrients and antioxidants that you don’t get in a bottle. What is more, since you control the ingredients, you regulate your calorie intake as well.

According to the Colorado State University Extension, chocolate milk is a popular post-workout drink. Note that one cup of low-chocolate milk encompasses 180 calories, 31 grams of carbs and 8 grams of protein. A better alternative might be to make your own meal replacement shakes.One suggestion might be blending a small banana with a cup of nonfat milk, and one tablespoon of peanut butter. Such a shake has 270 calories, 42 grams of carbs and 16 grams of protein. You can also consider adding Greek yogurt to your meal replacement shakes.

It is rich in protein and is a decent base for a nutritious post-workout smoothie. Blend 1 cup of blueberries, orange juice and a 6-ounce container of Greek yogurt to prepare a satisfying, thick shake of about 245 calories.

Based on studies, post-workout meal replacement shakes that encompass a blend of carbs and protein (3:1 ratio) are a practical way to assist your body in recovering.​

Organic Meal Replacement Shakes

Let’s move on to another popular subject - organic weight loss shakes. Considering that most meal replacement shakes you find on the market aren’t organic, what is left of you to do is prepare them at home. By using pristine, untouched ingredients that aren’t filled with harmful pesticides, you get the most out of your nutritious weight loss shakes.

Why Choose Organic Ingredients?

protein-shake ingredients

The obvious reason one might choose organic meal replacement shakes over conventional ones is that they are 100 percent free of pesticides, sewage-based fertilizers, and genetically modified organisms.

Also, organic dairy proteins aren’t derived from cows that are treated with antibiotics and hormones. Based on a study, organic foods offer extra antioxidants that equal eating 1-2 additional portions of veggies and fruits per day. The evidence is, indeed, overwhelming. Organic food is higher in antioxidants; hence, it is more beneficial for you.

If you wish to go down the path of organic meal replacement shakes, you should do-it-yourself. Homemade meal replacement shakes enable you to hand-pick each ingredient and calculate the vitamins and minerals per serving. This way, you expand your knowledge of nutritious meals and come up with ways of staying healthy and fit.

Start with a protein-rich base, such as organic Greek yogurt, plant-based or dairy milk, silken tofu, or organic protein powder. The next step is to add either frozen or fresh organic fruits for vitamins, minerals, and flavor. We recommend you to top off your meal replacement shakes with cinnamon, nut butter, cocoa powder, or rolled oats.

Vegan Meal Replacement Shakes

Whey protein

Nowadays, more and more people adopt a plant-based diet. According to official studies, these diets are linked to numerous health benefits, such as lower blood pressure, diminished risk of heart disease, low cholesterol, etc. This source indicates that a plant-based diet is also believed to lengthen the lifespan.

Nonetheless, most meal replacement protein shakes contain dairy proteins, casein or whey. These are a definite no-no for vegans. Even if you combine non-dairy milk or yogurt and fruits, you won’t get the benefits of a full meal.

You might lack protein, which is crucial. Don’t get us wrong: eating organic meal replacement shakes is still possible. All you have to do is pay attention to the ingredients you select so that you enjoy a great taste and optimal nutrition.​

Protein Choices

As we highlighted above, meal replacement shakes should contain protein. That stimulates the connectivity of the issues, strengthening your muscles. It gives you energy, supporting the health of your immune system. You can get protein from seeds, beans, nuts, and soy.

Keep in mind that there are some vegan protein ingredients, such as brown rice, pea, and hemp, that lack lysine, an important amino acid. So, you should eat quinoa, legumes and pumpkin seeds. This way, you make sure you get enough lysine.

Balance Is Primordial

The best shakes for weight loss offer essential phytonutrients, minus the high sugar content. When it comes to vegan meal replacement shakes, it’s easy to obtain an imbalanced result if you’re not careful. On that note, we recommend you to limit your weight loss shakes to ½ a cup of fruit, and add kale, spinach, celery, or other veggies.

Moreover, fat is another important component. It grants you the feeling of satiety. So, we advise you to include ground flax seeds or almond butter, a tablespoon of coconut oil or avocado, to benefit from healthy unsaturated fats. Omega-three fatty acids, for example, support the health of the cardiovascular system, while fighting inflammation.


Vegan Meal Replacement Shakes Recommendations

Making vegan meal replacement shakes is effortless. One suggestion might be to mix almond butter, spinach, banana, raspberries, and flax seeds. The result is a nutritious shake that includes plenty of vitamin A, healthy fats, omega-3 fatty acids, and the right amount of protein.

If you wish to enjoy the benefits of potassium and anti-inflammatory antioxidants you should also add avocado, coconut water, soy protein powder, and lemon. Moreover, if you want to stack up on protein and omega-3 fatty acids, combine soy milk, kale, hemp seeds and coconut butter.​

Final Thoughts

To conclude, the best meal replacement shakes are extremely useful for your health. They are easy to implement in any diet, and they aren’t restrictive. You can try numerous alternatives and tastes, depending on your personal preference. Also, you can come up with creative and healthy recipes for the best weight loss shakes.

Nonetheless, before you include the best meal replacement shakes in your diet, you should discuss with a registered dietitian or your personal physician.

If you want to improve your lifestyle by embracing a healthy diet, you are doing yourself a huge favor. Still, it is best to adopt a long-term, balanced regime including lean proteins, veggies, fruit, grains, and carbs. At the same time, you must make sure that the best weight loss shakes don’t replace your regular meals.

Also, by using low-calorie foods, such as veggies and fruits, you regulate your metabolism.

On a final note, losing weight with the help of the best meal replacement shakes is a possibility. Still, you must be patient because nothing happens overnight. Plus, remember that losing weight gradually is the right approach. Moderate exercise and calorie restriction will also enhance your overall health and will keep you fit.​

Leave a Comment: